Far from being the worlds greatest democracy, to quote president obama, representative democracy in the united states seems further hollowed out. Elections in the united states are held for government officials at the federal, state, and local levels. Its degree of democracy has been contested since its establishment in 1977, with graphs like the one below invariably present in spanish newspapers in the aftermath of the countrys general elections. Winnertakeall electoral system is a loser for democracy gop presidential candidates debate at the reagan library in 2011. These two major flaws in the us electoral system stand in.
The electoral college is not democratic vanity fair. Why isnt the electoral college considered undemocratic. The book defines democratic as alignment with the principle of one person, one vote, also known as majority rule. It is not a building or institution, rather the college is really just a way to name a group of 538 people who are the formal electors. The american political system is broken the washington post. Americas electoral system is outdated and undemocratic. Dec 16, 2016 a us president is elected via the electoral college system. The electoral college is a group of electors, outlined and defined in the united states constitution, established for the purpose of electing the president and vicepresident. Each state has two senators regardless of size, which dahl argues is undemocratic as smaller states have an increased prominence than they would otherwise have. The electoral college is an undemocratic mess whowhatwhy. The spanish electoral system is often referred to in such affectionate terms as a historical accident or machiavellian. The current us election system is a convoluted mess, its also undemocratic.
The primary advantage to the popular vote over the electoral college is that voters, regardless of state, are equally represented in the final, national vote tally. The electoral system can also be made more convenient through enhanced advance polling and absentee balloting. At the federal level, the nations head of state, the president, is elected indirectly by the people of each state, through an electoral college. Of course there are three types of bipartisan systems, one in which we have two maj. Reserved seat quotas simply mean that within the legislature, a certain number or percentage of seats called a quota will be set aside for an underrepresented. Abolishing the electoral college and creating a national popular vote are farfetched ideas for now. The united states is undemocratic by its very nature. Dahl that discusses seven undemocratic elements of the united states constitution. The system of safe seats and winner take all methods in results undermines the democratic one man one vote element of presidential elections. The us presidential electoral system is in effect a twostage decision system. The electoral college is a body of electors established by the united states constitution, which forms every four years for the sole purpose of electing the president and vice president of the united states. It has been criticized by some as an undemocratic anachronism, but praised by others as a pillar of political stability and american federalism. Maine and nebraska assign their electors using a proportional system. Christmas when demand for political controversy sometimes outweighs the systems ability to supply it.
The united states, invested in creating an image of democracy, suffers from several obstacles in the way of the election process that are powerful enough to question the democratic nature of the us voting system. The vast majority of americans venerate the constitution and the democratic principles it embodies, but many also worry that the united states has fallen behind other nations on crucial issues, including economic equality, racial. In what way is the us electoral system undemocratic. These showed no promise of actually overturning the. Nov 05, 2002 the us midterm elections could see a shift in political control. It certainly would not be an appropriate mechanism for most countries, but it is a workable solution to the uss unique geographicalpolitical pressures. An idea for electoral college reform that both parties. Dahls seven undemocratic elements politics tutor2u. John ashcroft, former united states attorney general. The united states needs to include inclusive citizenship in order to become more democratic. Another responder writes that i think the electoral college can be salvaged by eliminating the winner take all system. While others may say that america is a republic, the voting system is advertised as democratic, and therefore should be. While most americans have a basic understanding of the electoral college, far fewer of them know its an extraordinarily undemocratic system. The electoral college is outdated and undemocratic bartleby.
Support new america we are dedicated to renewing america by continuing the quest to realize our nations highest ideals, honestly confronting the challenges caused by rapid technological and social change, and seizing the opportunities those changes create. The original electoral college, which lasted only through the first four presidential elections, was a beautiful idea. The electoral college magnifies the margin of victory, thereby giving a new president a burst of momentum. Governments undemocratic elements, rooted in history. Our undemocratic constitution american academy of arts. How does electoral system favors small states answers. Electoral college is undemocratic des moines register. Americas unique and controversial electoral college. Aug 24, 2016 first past the post is the voting system we currently employ in canada at the federal level. In the oxford handbook of jurisprudence and the philosophy. Oct 18, 2016 the electoral college has 538 members, and each state has the same number of electors as it does house and senate seats.
Jay sekulows alarming and inspiring undemocratic is a mustread for anyone who wants to restore american greatness. It is likely that the final tallies from last weeks election will confirm. Using the popular vote would be the most obvious choice and a majority of americans support this change. These two major flaws in the us electoral system stand in the.
Why is the us electoral system labeled as free, fair and. Nov 06, 2012 the american electoral system explained. Democratic electoral systems around the world, 19462011. Donald trump will become the 45th president of the united states on jan. The electoral college, by contrast, is gratuitously, inexcusably undemocratic. The us electoral system contains a wide variety of arbitrary state rules and regulations, causing many to ask whether america is a democracy, or something else. It resembled the way a university chooses a new professor, and it had the same virtues. The electoral systems of 211 independent states and related. The diversity of state electoral systems and eligibility rules was a concern all the way back to the creation of the electoral college in 1787, and overhauling the system would also create immense. Democracy is not an end goal, its a solution to a problem. It is an unfair system which often gives all the power in each riding to a small number of people.
The electoral systems of the uk and the us differ a lot. The british state is a bourgeois democracy, with a hereditary constitutional monarchy. Oct 28, 2015 the electoral system can also be made more convenient through enhanced advance polling and absentee balloting. Fort knox is an army post in kentucky where the majority of u. The senate and the electoral college both stop that from happeningor at least limit it. Here, bbc news online explains the divisions of power, the elaborate electoral system and how it ties in with the us constitution. Hundreds of millions of dollars flow into the campaigns. The electoral college is the important and often controversial process by which the united states selects the president of the united states every four years. Electoral reform in the united states refers to efforts to change american elections and the electoral system used in the united states most elections in the u.
There will be another gop debate there in september. Weve never been and were unlikely to become one anytime soon. The international idea handbook of electoral system design ifes. The electoral college is an outdated system the united states uses in the presidential elections and it is a system that is fundamentally not representing each citizen equally. Commonly, people will mention that small states are accorded much more power in the electoral college this is very true. The electoral college is undemocratic in the sense that it is violates the principle of one person, one vote. Adams said about gerrymandering and disenfranchising, i must add that any bipartisan system is inherently unfree, unfair and undemocratic. Nov 17, 2000 the united states of america is first foremost a union.
Drew penrose, legal director at the election reform advocacy organization fairvote, notes that the electoral college is particularly flawed because. Us electoral system suggests democracy died long ago. An idea for electoral college reform that both parties might actually like the way we now elect presidents would horrify the authors of the u. The electoral college is antidemocraticand thats a good. Unconstitutional and unfair to voters in 48 states they are unfair to republicans and democrats alike, and dont need a constitutional amendment to fix. It is the purpose of this essay to critically evaluate the ways through which the us original constitution was both democratic and undemocratic. The us president and vice president are not elected directly by the people. A candidate needs the vote of at least 270 electorsmore than half of all electorsto win the presidential. Today, these electors almost always vote with the popular vote of their state. This report focuses on the institutions and procedures associated with the contemporary electoral college system. The united states department of the treasury is in charge of fort knox. On saturday, i wrote up a startling fact, brought to my attention by the organization fairvote, about american politics.
Electors are chosen to represent their states voters and, about one month later, officially confirm the winner through a mostly symbolic vote. The framers of the original constitution of the us can be credited for creating a republic rather than a democracy. Firstpastthepost voting system undemocratic, warns ippr. Every four years, americans choose their next president using a unique if not controversial and even arcane system called the electoral college. To improve the performance of our website, show the most relevant news products and targeted advertising, we collect technical impersonal information about you, including through the. It is a very peculiar bourgeois democracy because of its cobbled together, iterative,constitutional structure adapted over centuries to take account of the demands of the rising social classes of, first, the capitalist bourgeoisie, and from the late 19th century onwards, the modern working class. Jan 08, 2015 on saturday, i wrote up a startling fact, brought to my attention by the organization fairvote, about american politics. M any people whine that using the electoral college instead of the popular vote and majority rule is undemocratic. Jul 08, 2008 the electoral college setup exposes the fundamentally undemocratic nature of the u. But, like any form of government, it is also prone to manipulation. The united kingdom uses different electoral systems and among them we could mention. Figure 2 shows the relationship between gerrymandering and the electoral system employed in every country countries using pr systems score lower 2.
The us electoral system is undemocratic the article ii, section 1 of the us constitution, establishes the electoral college which was made clear in 2000. Representation in the electoral college is not proportional due to the addition of two. A group voting ticket gvt is a simplified preferential voting system currently in use for elections to the victorian legislative council and western australian legislative council, the upper houses of two australian state legislatures. Comparatively, individuals in wyoming have nearly four times the power in the electoral college as californians. Nov 30, 2016 in fact the electoral college system was created by slaveholders, and remains undemocratic and racist, and biased to the republicans. Nov 08, 2016 thanks to the current system, small states are given much more weight and candidates only bother to show up in a few tightly contested states. The founding fathers created the electoral college system as a compromise between having the president elected by congress and having the president elected by the popular vote of. A candidate needs the vote of at least 270 electorsmore than half of all electorsto win the presidential election. Democratic and undemocratic elements of the constitution. Obama showed that the system can be overcome and even turned to our advantage, but the clinton and gore losses show it is an uphill climb. But theres a more targeted way to reform american elections by 2020starting with the. The electoral college is an antidemocratic institution. The senate is undemocratic and it matters realclearpolitics. Bottom line, yes, the electoral college system is not only undemocratic it is antidemocratic, in that it directly stifles the vote of the masses in exchange for a few power players i.
Electoral college imperfect but preserves federalism best. Identify three rules of the united states electoral system that acts as obstacles to minor party candidates winning elections and explain how each acts as an obstacle rules of the electoral system is more specific than obstacles to minor parties. Reserved seat quotas international knowledge network of. The electoral college method of electing a president of the united states is.
Us electoral college acts against democracy letter us. The electoral college method of electing a president of the united states is archaic, undemocratic, complex,ambiguous, indirect, anddangerous. Jan 04, 2011 the firstpastthepost voting system can produce undemocratic results, according to research by a leftleaning thinktank that warns that labour could be returned to power in future. It would have prevented the us from emerging as a stable union. Instead, they are chosen by electors through a process called the electoral college. Dec 20, 2016 ben jacobss article on the us electoral college misses the point entirely about its founding and its profoundly undemocratic nature how does the electoral college vote work and can it stop. But the presidentelect has benefited from the system he dubbed undemocratic. In the new senate, the 46 democrats will have received 20 million more. The electoral college consists of 538 electors, and an absolute majority of at. In his book how democratic is the american constitution, he outlines seven. In this provocative book, one of our most eminent political scientists poses the question, why should americans uphold their constitution. The electoral college, far from being a curious relic, plays a vital part in preserving that union. Nov 30, 2016 clearly, these people do not understand that the electoral college is the most undemocratic part of our democracy.
The electoral college is a problem in american democracy. If no candidate reaches the 270 mark, the election is decided by the house of representatives. Christopher reed, the business times singapore, 12 oct. Sep 20, 2016 however, there is one shocking fact that most of our population has either no knowledge, or is unaware of, and that is that the popular vote doesnt decide much of the election outcome for the president of the united states. As you wait for election results to come in, watch these three short videos to learn more about the electoral college and the mess it is. Few americans would contend today that if we were designing a system to elect a president from scratch, the electoral college would be the optimal solution. The united states of america and great britain have a lot of in common but the same times have a number of differences. This is the system more commonly referred to as the electoral college, and it is a completely undemocratic system, for. Sean hannity if you read just one book this year, read undemocratic and prepare to have your eyes opened to the true crisis facing our republic. Canadas first past the post electoral system is undemocratic.
There is a good reason the founders did not create a direct democracy. Another issue that shows the united states undemocratic ways has to do with fort knox. It was also previously used in federal and several australian state elections that used the single transferable vote system. The system of safe seats and winner take all methods in results undermines. On january 8, 2015, sri lanka held a presidential election. In the smallest state, wyoming, each elector represents 200,000 people.
488 849 241 1080 63 213 493 322 258 1258 1319 833 660 458 827 674 1079 1335 1312 794 1450 1444 941 1523 120 1119 861 4 401 1336 326 1460 621 694 958 694 102 604 1006 523 1213 211 683